Are comic books based on doomed movies?

While many films based on comic books have enjoyed some degree of success, comics based on films are more likely to fail.


In recent years, cinematic adaptations of classic picture books have been a huge hit. Comic book fans have consumed movie after movie based on heroes like captain AmericaAnd the Iron ManAnd the amazing womanAnd the Batman In both the Marvel Cinematic Universe and the DC Extended Universe. Filmmakers have leveraged decades of source material to develop their massive interlocking cinematic adventures, and artistic freedom has enabled them to craft stories that appeal to audiences and fundamentalists alike.


However, comic book authors have struggled for years to turn movies into respectable books. Series after series ended in short periods with a few exceptions. Most of them fell victim to the horrific curse of “comics adaptation” and ended abruptly. The relative failure to adapt popular films to comic books can be traced back to many famous Hollywood films of the 20th century for various reasons.

RELATED: Star Wars Presents The Empire’s Terrifying View on Iron Man


Potentially intriguing storylines fall prey to the curse of comic book adaptation

after success Willow In 1988 (directed by Ron Howard) marvel Published three-issue limited series based on the film. The film followed closely, adding little to the original, and was the last iteration of Willow Ufgood’s story in comic book form. Willow demonstrated the potential for expansion as evidenced by the upcoming Disney+ series and the enduring popularity of the original movie. However, recreating a film on the comic page may provide ordinary readers with little incentive to invest in a series and may limit its appeal to collectors. Neglecting to build on a story while adapting to a different medium can lead to mediocre results as was the case with Marvel’s Willow.

planet of the apes (directed by Franklin J. Schaffner and written by Rod Serling – based on a novel by Pierre Paul) It was a hugely popular movie in 1968. It wasn’t until the release of Under the Planet of the Apes who – which gold key comics He released a comic book adaptation in 1970. Marvel continued the franchise in 1974 by following through on films and subsequent publishers thereafter experimented with crossovers such as Star TrekAnd the king kong characterAnd the Tarzan. Unfortunately, franchising with off-brand characters can often appear as a marketing ploy rather than a legitimate attempt to expand on its own story. It should also be noted that the filmmakers of the 1968 production took a completely different approach to the source material with positive results. Remaking the book into a movie probably won’t yield the same results, as evidenced by 2009 guardsDirected by Zack Snyder. Reviews were mixed while many critics noted that the screen’s straightforward interpretation did not translate well.

Related: King Kong once found himself on the Planet of the Apes

The Star Wars Machine Can’t Be Stopped

There are damn exceptions. The star Wars The comic book line (by Roy Thomas and Howard Chaykin) began with a six-part series based on the film and followed up with over a hundred issues. The sheer popularity of movies is the reason why comic books have been able to last for decades and have spawned so many stories and chapters. Few franchises have managed to replicate this level of achievement in multiple media. alien (directed by Ridley Scott) produced an adaptation called Alien: Storyboard (By Archie Goodwin and Walter Simonson). It was the first comic book to be included in The New York Times Bestseller List Despite sticking with the movie, it won huge awards in large part for its masterful adaptation of the screenplay. In addition, the artwork for his creation was praised.

The dazzling big screen visuals or the dramatic dialogue of Hollywood stars can sometimes get lost on the illustrated page. Often, what works in another medium may not work in another medium without due respect for both. Condensing a massive epic from the big screen to the limitations of a comic book may leave readers with a watered-down version. With few exceptions, a strict interpretation of the scenario often leads to lackluster results. A series that seizes an opportunity to bypass a simple “comic book edit” may have better prospects for long-term readers built on a stronger foundation.

#comic #books #based #doomed #movies

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *